Certainteed Charcoal Black vs Moire Black Shingles

Thinking about a new roof but stuck choosing the perfect shingle color? You're not alone. One of the most common decisions homeowners face is CertainTeed Charcoal Black vs Moire Black—two bold, beautiful options in the CertainTeed Landmark line. They look similar at first glance, but slight differences can completely change your home's curb appeal.

In this blog, we’ll compare the two colors side by side, walk you through what really matters when choosing between them, and explain how Restoration Roofing can help you make the right call and conduct your new roof replacement.

Comparing Certainteed Charcoal Black vs Moire Black Shingles

If you’re choosing between two of CertainTeed’s most popular colors, you’re likely weighing the pros and cons of CertainTeed Landmark Charcoal Black vs Moire Black. While both shingles share the same high-performance features and warranties, their most significant differences come down to color tone, contrast, and curb appeal. Let’s break down how these two black roof shingles are similar and differ.

The Similarities

Although they look slightly different on the roof, CertainTeed Charcoal Black and Moire Black shingles are more alike than not. Here’s how both shingle colors in the Landmark® series stack up:

Equal Durability

Both Moire Black and Charcoal Black shingles are made with CertainTeed’s QuadraBond™ technology, which bonds the layers of each shingle for maximum strength. They also include CertaSeal™, a high-performance adhesive that resists wind uplift, moisture intrusion, and structural shifting over time. Regardless of which color you choose, you’ll get the same strong, long-lasting protection from the elements.

Similar Warranty Coverage

These shingles both come with CertainTeed’s lifetime limited warranty, giving homeowners confidence in the product’s long-term reliability. You’ll also receive SureStart™ coverage for the first 10 years, which includes full reimbursement for materials, labor, and tear-off if there’s a defect. Additionally, both options feature 15-year algae resistance thanks to copper-infused granules built to combat streaking and discoloration.

Architectural Style Fit

Whether your home is modern, traditional, colonial, or craftsman-style, both shingle colors offer broad aesthetic appeal. They’re designed to complement various exteriors, from light-colored siding to red brick. As part of the CertainTeed Landmark shingles lineup, both Moire and Charcoal are flexible options for nearly any architectural design.

The Differences

While the materials and performance are identical, the most significant differences between Moire Black vs Charcoal Black shingles come down to visual impact. Here’s how both options differ:

Color Variation

Charcoal Black is the darkest color available in the Landmark series and features more visible color contrast between granules, creating a layered look. Moire Black, on the other hand, leans slightly more gray and has less dramatic color shifting.

Visual Uniformity

Moire Black shingles are known for their smooth, consistent appearance, making them an excellent choice for homeowners who prefer a clean, even tone. Charcoal Black provides more dimension with subtle shifts between dark grays and blacks, which can add depth to simpler rooflines.

Lighting Impact

Lighting plays a big role in how these shingles appear once installed. Moire Black tends to look lighter in direct sunlight and can appear more gray on cloudy days. Charcoal Black holds its deep, bold tone more consistently, even in different lighting conditions. This can be important if your roof is highly visible or you want your home to have strong contrast and curb appeal year-round.

Key Considerations When Choosing Certainteed Moire Black vs Charcoal Black Roof Shingles

Picking the right shingle color can change how your whole house looks—and how it fits in with everything around it. When comparing CertainTeed Landmark Moire Black vs Charcoal Black, the decision isn’t just about which color looks better in a sample—it's about how each option works with your siding, lighting, and surrounding homes.

Siding Color Match

Your siding plays a huge role in how your roof color shows up. Moire Black shingles tend to blend well with lighter, warmer siding tones like cream, beige, or off-white, offering a softer contrast. Charcoal Black, with its deeper shade and stronger contrast, pairs better with bold colors like red brick, navy, or even white siding when you want a crisp, dramatic finish.

Lighting and Sun Exposure

Lighting can influence how both shingle colors appear throughout the day. Moire Black tends to look lighter and grayer under full sun, making it a good fit for homes with high sun exposure that want a more balanced, neutral look. Charcoal Black holds its depth and intensity no matter the lighting, which works great if you want consistent, bold curb appeal all day long.

Neighborhood Aesthetics

Looking around your neighborhood can help you decide which color will complement—or stand out from—the homes nearby. Moire Black blends more naturally in traditional, softer-toned communities, creating a classic and uniform look. Charcoal Black fits right in with more modern neighborhoods or custom builds where bold, high-contrast roofs are a statement feature.

Hire Maryland’s #3-rated CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster Team

When it comes to full roof replacements, you need more than just good shingles—you need a team you can trust to install them right. Restoration Roofing is proud to be ranked the #3 CertainTeed roofing contractor in Maryland, and we specialize exclusively in full roof replacements. Our certification as a Select ShingleMaster means we meet CertainTeed’s highest standards for workmanship, knowledge, and customer service.

We deliver value and peace of mind on every project. Here’s what that means for you:

• Certified Installation Expertise: Every roof is installed by professionals trained and certified through CertainTeed’s Select ShingleMaster program.

• Manufacturer-Backed Warranties: You get a 25-year labor warranty and a 50-year material warranty directly from CertainTeed.

• Seamless Experience: From consultation to cleanup, we make the process easy and stress-free.

With Restoration Roofing, you get the trusted durability of CertainTeed Landmark shingles—plus the local experience to install them right the first time.

Conclusion: Choosing Between Moire Black vs Charcoal Black CertainTeed Shingles

In conclusion, when deciding between the two different—but similar—CertainTeed asphalt shingles, it all comes down to the look you’re going for. Both are built with the same strength, algae resistance, and warranty protection. However, Moire Black offers a softer, more uniform tone that suits light or traditional exteriors, while Charcoal Black gives a darker, bolder contrast ideal for modern styles or high-impact curb appeal.

Not sure which one will look best on your home? Book a free appointment with Restoration Roofing today or visit our website to get your estimate. We’ll help you choose the perfect color and get the job done right.